Mar 11, 2022

Prevention of Sexual Harassment: Recent Developments

Recently, the Calcutta High Court dealt with a case of sexual harassment as alleged against a teacher of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti by several female students. This is one of the recent cases in which the Supreme Court and different High Courts have clarified the scope of sexual harassment at the workplace laws. 

Almost 24 years ago, the Supreme Court issued guidelines to prevent sexual harassment of women in the famous Vishakha judgement. In 2013, the Parliament enacted the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 (POSH Act). Yet, even now, , it is not clear how effective it has been to combat the evil of sexual harassment, especially for women in the informal sector. We discuss some recent important developments below. 

  • In sexual harassment cases, courts should not apply service rules in a hypertechnical manner

In a recent case, which involved allegations of sexual harassment of a juniour colleague by a BSF constable, the Security Force Court (Internal Committee) of the BSF, had found the constable guilty of sexual harassment. The High Court, in appeal, invalidated the entire proceedings because it found that the original enquiry report had mentioned the wrong date of the occurrence of the event. Asking for an additional enquiry report was beyond the BSF Rules. 

In this context, the Supreme Court said that as it takes a lot of courage for a subordinate to file a complaint of sexual harassment against their superior, courts should not apply the organization’s service rules in a hyper-technical manner and invalidate sexual harassment proceedings. 

 The Supreme Court restored the punishment of the constable. It said that courts should interpret rules about sexual harassment at the workplace in a manner that provided substantive justice to the parties. 

  • Confidentiality of sexual harassment proceedings does not mean that  perpetrators will not be held responsible

A few months ago, the Bombay High Court laid down guidelines on conducting hearings, passing orders, and reporting of sexual harassment cases. The High Court said that they would hear such cases either “in camera” (without the press or the general public) or in the judge’s chamber. Media can only report on such cases with the judge’s permission. They also stated that any violation of the guidelines would amount to contempt of court. An appeal challenging these guidelines is pending before the Supreme Court.

 

The intention behind these guidelines was to protect the identities of the survivors of sexual harassment. However, the restrictions on accessing the orders and judgements in a case of sexual harassment, and the blanket ban on any kind of reporting about the case end up benefitting the perpetrator more than the survivor of sexual harassment. Granting secrecy to the perpetrator even after the court case has finished and they have been found guilty (or allowing media to report on it only with the Court’s permission) prevents exposure of perpetrators. They can continue their pattern of abuse and harassment.

 

  1. POSH Act applies to girl students of a school

 

In the most recent case,  the Calcutta High Court held that female students in a school are included in the definition of “aggrieved woman” as per Section 2(a) of the POSH Act. Complaints of such students related to sexual harassment should be heard by an Internal Complaints Committee set up by the school.

 

While schools and universities may not be the workplace of girl students, they are certainly the workplace of teachers. The POSH Act requires every organization, public or private, to set up an Internal Complaints Committee (ICC).So, once there is a sexual harassment complaint, it has to be dealt with by the ICC, irrespective of whether the “aggrieved woman” (in this case the student) is employed at the workplace or not. This broad interpretation of the application of the POSH Act creates more avenues for sexual harassment survivors to seek redressal.

 

Related Weekly Posts

February 24 2022

Addressing Sexual Harassment within the Supreme Court

Trigger Warning: This post contains information on physical violence and sexual violence which some readers may find disturbing.   The Gender Sensitisation and Internal Complaints Committee (GSICC) of the Supreme Court has found Ashok Saini, the clerk of an advocate, guilty of sexual harassment within Court premises. Saini has been debarred from entering the Court […]
Read More >

March 06 2022

Can you file a complaint when the police harass you?

The Delhi High Court condemned the Delhi Police for conducting an illegal raid at 2.30 in the morning. It issued directions for the same. What is police harassment? Police harassment is when a police officer goes beyond their assigned duties to take advantage of a citizen in their official capacity. This can take many forms, […]
Read More >

February 24 2022

Did you know: A sexual harassment complaint can be filed against another woman in the workplace

The Calcutta High Court has said that same-gender complaints are permitted under the law on sexual harassment at the workplace. The Court held that people of the same gender can complain of sexual harassment against each other. A person of any gender can commit acts of sexual harassment at the workplace.    If a workplace […]
Read More >

March 11 2022

The Menace of Online Harassment

Two names have been in the news a lot lately – ‘Bulli Bai’ and ‘Sulli Deals’. The Delhi and Mumbai Police have made several arrests across the country in connection with these names. Let’s find out what the controversy is all about. What are the ‘Bulli Bai’ and ‘Sulli Deals’ apps? ‘Sulli Deals’ was an […]
Read More >

March 04 2022

What should you know about sexual harassment at the workplace?

The Madras High Court has said that personal feuds or mere misunderstandings with a superior cannot be the basis for a complaint of sexual harassment at the workplace.   What is sexual harassment at the workplace? Sexual harassment at the workplace includes the following unwelcome acts or behavior (whether directly or indirectly):   (i) physical […]
Read More >

February 23 2022

4 Things You Need to Know About Transgender Rights and ID Proof in India

Identification documents play a major role in facilitating your rights such as the right to healthcare, education, etc. and are also important for day-to-day activities such as applying for a SIM Card or a bank account, etc.   Did you know that… …it is your right to get identification documents recognizing the gender you want […]
Read More >

February 26 2022

Who are the authorities implementing the law against workplace sexual harassment?

The Maharashtra Government has appointed authorities under the workplace sexual harassment law, more than seven years after it came into force. In this context, let us look at why these authorities are important.   Which authorities can you approach against workplace sexual harassment? Internal Committee: Every employer employing at least ten workers at a workplace […]
Read More >

March 11 2022

5 Things You Didn’t Know About Law on Rape

The two heinous gang rapes of dalit women in Hathras and Balrampur, Uttar Pradesh, has raised a lot of questions regarding laws and protections available to women in the country, especially those belonging to lower castes. Here are five things you need to know about the law relating to the crime of rape 1.Punishment for […]
Read More >

March 11 2022

5 things you didn’t know about Cruelty by Husbands

The Bombay High Court has said that nowadays, it has become a habit to make vague accusations of cruelty against a husband’s family members. In its order, the Court said that when a husband or his relatives are accused of being cruel to his wife, the accusation should be carefully examined by the Court to […]
Read More >

March 11 2022

5 things you didn’t know about the rights of Same-sex Couples

The Delhi High Court has taken up two petitions dealing with marriage equality for same-sex couples. The petitions seek that the Special Marriage Act (SMA) and Foreign Marriage Act (FMA) should apply to all couples regardless of gender identity and sexual orientation. The Court has asked the Central government to respond to these petitions. Is […]
Read More >

February 26 2022

Can you get protection if you file a criminal complaint or witness a crime?

The survivor in the alleged rape case against former Karnataka Minister Ramesh Jarkiholi has written to the Karnataka High Court Chief Justice seeking protection for her life and safety. She asked the Court to take note of the threat she is facing, claiming that the Special Investigation Team (SIT) probing the case is acting in […]
Read More >