I moved to Australia for a job assignment in January 2016, but my wife chose to stay in India. We both discussed this arrangement and consented to it. Now she is filing for divorce claiming that I deserted her, but my intention was never to do so. Can I object to the divorce? Is her reason a valid one in Hindu law?

No, if you never intended to abandon her, then she cannot claim desertion as a ground for divorce. Intention to desert a spouse plays an important role in getting a decree of divorce. However, you must also make that clear in your response to her divorce petition.

What will the Court take into consideration while finally deciding a divorce case for Hindu marriage?

In the end, the Court will keep in mind the following circumstances while making a decision:

  • The best interest of of your children.
  • Any possibility of reconciliation between the you and your spouse.
  • In cases of cruelty,
    • The nature of the conduct or cruel treatment. For example, the Court would consider whether your spouse is harassing you for money or does acts to humiliate you.
    • The impact of such treatment on the mind of the spouse and whether it would be harmful or injurious to his or her life. For example, if your spouse harasses you for dowry, then it would impact you monetarily and affect your marital life.

My husband keeps coming to my office and harassing me at work in front of my employer. Can I file for a divorce under Hindu law?

Continuous harassment by your spouse may amount to mental cruelty in some cases, and may even be valid grounds for a divorce. However generally, actions such as creating hurdles relating to your professional life, or humiliating you in front of your colleagues or boss, need to be in addition to other actions such as instituting dishonest cases against you, etc.

However, there is no one strict formula for granting a divorce, and each order for divorce is granted based on the specific facts of your case. Therefore, depending on factors such as the extent of harassment, the mental trauma you have suffered, and the regularity of these occurrences, a divorce may be granted. For legal advice relevant to your experiences, please contact a lawyer.

Can I file for a divorce simply because my marriage is not working out under Hindu law?

Under Hindu Divorce law you cannot easily file for divorce simply because you unilaterally believe that your marriage is not working out. The Courts have recognized that “Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage” is a situation where either one or both spouses are no longer able or willing to live with each other, thereby ending their marital relationship with no hope for its revival. The law does not specifically recognise this as a reason for divorce, but some courts have accepted it to be a valid ground. However, it would be hard to successfully get a divorce simply on this ground.

If my husband did not intend to behave in a cruel manner with me, can I still go to Court to file a case of cruelty under Hindu law?

Just because your spouse did not intend to hurt you or harass you, does not mean that it is not an act of cruelty. The intention of your spouse does not matter. Unintentional acts also amount to cruelty. For example, if your husband has a habit of beating you under the influence of alcohol, the excuse of him not “intending” to beat you, will not matter – it would still be an act of physical cruelty and you can go to the Court to file for a divorce.

What are some examples of cruel behaviour that Courts have looked at under Hindu law?

Courts look at all acts of cruel behaviour that happen during the marriage and after filing the divorce. Some of the common cases of cruelty which go to Courts are:

  • Demands of money or dowry leading to harassment and continuous ill-treatment which may happen before or after your marriage.
  • A spouse registering various criminal cases or filing frivolous/multiple cases against you, leading to harassment.
  • Getting advertisements and news published to hurt your reputation.
  • When a spouse does not have sexual relations with you for a long time.
  • Allegations of extramarital relationships.
  • Ill-treatment by in-laws.

Can the act of cruelty be an isolated incident under Hindu law?

Cruelty is not a singular or isolated act done by one of the spouses. It has to be of such a nature that it is recurring or continuing over a period of time. However, there may be cases where a single conduct is bad enough or is an illegal act such as domestic violence. In such cases, Courts may consider such acts as acts of cruelty and grant the divorce.

What is my marital status if my husband dies during the divorce proceeding under Hindu law?

In a situation where the spouse who filed for divorce dies, the divorce proceeding would be discontinued and therefore you would be a widow, not a divorcee. A divorcee is a divorced person.

In a situation where you have filed for divorce and your husband dies, the divorce proceedings may not necessarily be discontinued because certain legal obligations continue after his death. Therefore, your case for divorce can continue and you may claim maintenance from the legal heirs of your husband. Depending on the decision of the court, you will not only be a widow but also a divorcee.

My wife is a qualified dentist but isn’t currently working. Can the Court still order me to pay her temporary maintenance for the course of the divorce proceedings under Hindu law?

Yes, the Court can order you to pay her temporary maintenance. It does not matter if she has earning capacity or not or whether she is qualified or not. If she does not have any source of income during the course of the proceedings, she can make an application for temporary maintenance and the Court can grant her the same.

Can I file for divorce if my husband is mentally ill under Muslim law?

Yes, you can go to the Court to file divorce against your husband if your husband is suffering from mental illness. However, your husband should be suffering from mental illness for at least 2 years before you approach the Court. It is better to consult a lawyer to understand more.

I am a Muslim man and my wife filed a divorce case against me stating that I am impotent. This in fact is untrue. She has already obtained a decree from Court so what can I do?

If your wife has filed a case against you saying that you are impotent, and if this is untrue, you can deny these allegations by going to Court with the assistance of a lawyer. Even if you are impotent, under the law, you have every right to file an application asking for time (one year) to prove to the Court that you have ceased to be impotent.

Can I annul my marriage under Muslim law?

Under Muslim personal laws, if a marriage is conducted by violating certain rules and customs, then they are known as Batil marriages. These kind of marriages can be annulled by going to Court. If you do annul such a marriage, then it would be as if the marriage never took place.

Can I divorce my wife by saying talaq, talaq, talaq at once under Muslim law?

No you cannot divorce your wife this way.

In 2017, Courts viewed talaq al- ba’in or triple talaq as a form of divorce which is no longer valid and one which cannot be practiced by husbands in India.

In this type of divorce, you can divorce your wife with three pronouncements of divorce at the same sitting. The effect of Triple Talaq is that the marriage comes to an immediate end once it is pronounced.

This form of divorce, left no room for the husband to change his mind nor did it give the woman any say in the way her own marriage ends.

For example, Arshaf says “Talaq, Talaq, Talaq” while looking at his wife one afternoon. Instantly, the marriage and marital obligations comes to an end. There would only be certain legal obligations between them which would remain, such as the husband or wife cannot inherit money or property from each other.

As of today, such divorces are illegal under the law and even if you do it, you would not be divorced from your wife.

What is talaq under Muslim law?

Talaq is divorce under Islam. Each School of Muslim law has a different approach to ending a marriage.

For example, the practice followed by the Ithna Ashari School is that they have to orally say the word talaq in front of two Muslim males who would be witnesses to the divorce and they have to say a certain set of words to end the marriage.

Can a parent file a maintenance application against more than one child or relative?

Yes, you can. As a parent, you can file your maintenance application against all your children. All of them have a duty to maintain you. As a senior citizen (without children), you can file your maintenance application against any or all relatives who possess or will inherit your property. If there is more than one such relative, each relative is supposed to pay maintenance in proportion to the property that they will inherit from you.

Can the amount of maintenance given to a parent or senior citizen, change at a later time depending on the situation?

Yes. The amount of maintenance can be altered/increased by approaching the court, if there are changes in your requirements like increase in cost of medical treatment. However, do remember that the amount can also be decreased depending on whether you now have an additional source of income or your requirements have decreased. It can also be canceled – for example, if you have converted to another religion and are no longer a Hindu, the judge may cancel payments as you are no longer eligible to receive maintenance under Hindu law.